Gary Shetter

Here at the Shetter Agency, our goal is to provide you with fair policies, reliable advice, and a sense of security that will help your family live well and thrive!

Meet the Team

Gary Shetter

Agency Owner

A native of south Pennsylvania, from the historic city of Chambersburg, Gary has been in the insurance industry for over 3 decades. Gary gets most excited about the prospect of helping people through the navigation of the insurance world and helping through education on making the best decisions for his clients and his clients’ families.

On a personal level, Gary spends his free time giving back to the community by dedicating his time to the Lions Club International where he can see the impact of the organization has on people all over the world. Additionally, he enjoys sampling different flavors of craft beer and spending the spring and fall months in the outdoors often enjoying the weather riding his bike as much as possible.

(814) 652-2711

Helen Grim

Helen is our local liaison. Born and raised in Altoona, she is the perfect fit for our agency because she comes straight out of the direct community we serve. She has a passion for people and doing everything she can to help especially with their insurance needs.

In her free time, Helen enjoys spending with her adult toddler who is only four years old but tries to act like he is 20. She enjoys people watching and studying how they act in different situations. Her free time is usually spent running errands to support her friends and family.

(814) 944-4651

Kirsten College


Kirsten is our hometown hero from Everett, PA. She most looks forward to meeting new people every day and getting involved with her fellow community members and finding commonality with them. The insurance world could be confusing so her favorite aspects of being a part of the agency include educating in the basics of insurance and helping generate quotes that are specific to people’s needs. 

Her pride and joy come from her two children and her husband. Kirsten’s free time is mostly spent with family. They enjoy going on small road trips to explore new places and experiences with each other.

(814) 652-2711

Lisa Browell

I have been working for GMS Insurance for almost 18 years. During my time here, I’ve been able to form connections with the policyholders coming in regularly. I strive to answer all their insurance needs to better understand the coverages they carry and why.

I was born in Bedford, Pennsylvania, and now live outside Everett, Pennsylvania. When I’m not working, I enjoy visiting my loved ones, especially my two daughters.

I like to spend time at home with my pets! Whenever I’m not cuddled up with my furry friends, I enjoy gardening or doing special projects around the house.


Missy Shetter

Missy has been working within the insurance industry for about 30 years now. Her many years of experience are made obvious by her natural ability to serve others. As a veteran member of the GMS Insurance team, Missy uses her knowledge of the industry to create lasting connections with customers to understand and meet their unique insurance needs. 

Missy was born and raised in Everett, PA. She enjoys spending quality time with her children and grandchildren in her free time. Her favorite way to spend the weekend is being surrounded by her loved ones.